The race for the 2025 American League MVP has become a showdown between two stars: Aaron Judge of the Yankees and Cal Raleigh of the Mariners. Both have had outstanding seasons, but their achievements and statistics offer different perspectives, sparking intense debate among journalists and baseball fans.

Aaron Judge, the Yankees’ outfielder, has experienced a remarkable transformation in his game. He is currently batting .326, leading the league in on-base percentage (.451) and slugging (.677), with 49 home runs and 105 RBIs. His WAR of 9.2 is the highest in the American League, highlighting his overall value to the team. He has also significantly reduced his strikeout rate while improving contact without losing power, solidifying himself as one of the most complete hitters of the season.

On the other hand, Cal Raleigh, the Mariners’ catcher, is having a historic season for his position. With 58 home runs, he has broken the Mariners’ record previously held by Ken Griffey Jr. and Mickey Mantle’s record for switch-hitters. He also leads the league with 121 RBIs and was selected as the starting catcher for the All-Star Game. His .949 OPS ranks among the best in the league, emphasizing the impact of his offensive performance.

In summary, the MVP choice will depend on what voters value more: Aaron Judge’s consistency and power or Cal Raleigh’s historic offensive output. One thing is certain: both have delivered memorable performances in the 2025 season, giving fans an exciting finish to the year.